My highest level book club used this resource as discussion prompts. How to build meaningful student led discussion pack meaningful student led discussion stems. Pros and cons of classroom group discussions owlcation. One of the first paired discussion strategies i used as a student teacher was the good old thinkpairshare or, as i call it, elbowbuddy talk. For the last five years, damms students have used the shared inquiry method of learning, developed by the great books foundation. After their shared inquiry discussions, each student writes a reflection. Teaching students how to lead and participate in productive book discussions. Students then use the strategy to develop questions for a peerled book discussion. It includes advice on how to introduce and cultivate student led discussions about literary and informational material at any grade. Introduce and cultivate student led discussions about literary and informational material at any grade. After two rounds of response and writing, the paper is passed a third time. We use cookies to ensure that we give you the best experience on our website. These groups can be organized in a variety of ways.
Seven tips for implementing studentled discussions. Decide on the number of student led book discussions you will have each week. Lets first identify some characteristics of studentled conversations with book clubs. For the discussion, students create their own questions and respond to their classmates over the most recent work of liter. Although guided instruction is teacher led, this does not mean that students are not talking.
The number will change and depend on other reading experiences that you offer students. Literature circles resource centerteaching students how to discuss. They enjoyed the step up to student led and facilitated literature circle. A small group of students created 34 activities and related discussions to enhance the weeks lesson. Among such resources are links to authentic video clips of students engaged in discussions. Most discussions move too quickly, says riley, and great ideas get totally lost. A short response is that in teacher led discussions the teacher typically asks questions, calls on students to respond, and manages the flow of conversations, while in student led discussions the students develop their own questions, work collaboratively, and facilitate the flow of their talk. In studentled discussions, author sandi novak offers you the resources you need to develop meaningful studentled conversations about text and media across the content areas.
Develop meaningful student led conversations about text and media across the content areas. Afterward, she enthusiastically shared what she had learned about facilitating effective student led discussions. This is my sixth post in my eight post series about implementing book clubs into your classroom. Common core facilitating studentled discussions georgia. She has more than 30 years of experience as an assistant superintendent, principal, curriculum and professional learning director, and teacher. This may indicate that the class needs a minilesson on that component of student led discussions. Oct 16, 2014 listen for how students personalize the discussion, and encourage them to develop their own voice. In my class, unprepared students read the pages in class before joining their group. As part of a collaborative study, wea firstgrade teacher and two universitybased researchersset a goal to facilitate meaningful, student led discussions about literature. Last week, i wrote about accountability with book clubs, which you can read more about here. Student led discussion groups these types of small groups are led by a student and meant to stimulate discussion on a given topic. While leading and listening to mathematical discussions, i am gaining a clearer picture of my students understanding as well as their misunderstandings.
Introduce and cultivate studentled discussions about literary and informational material at any grade. Give students the language they need to ask a question or reply with a comment or relevant thought during a discussion. As i mentioned in my first blog post, i moved away from assigning roles, such as super summarizer or cool connector because it limited my students discussions. You need enough members to offer diverse perspectives, but a small enough group for every voice to be heard. Great books, great student discussions weareteachers.
The instructor is available to answer questions and guide the discussion if necessary, but the emphasis is on the exchange of student ideas to help students see a variety of views on a given topic. What follows are ideas for organizing and managing student led discussions, tips for using the cards, and prompts that students can use to jumpstart stalled discussions. Resources for educators whether you already do studentled conferences or are interested in making a shift, this list includes a variety of goto examples, guides, tips, and forms to help launch or improve these meetings. While i am decidedly a novice in using math talk in my classroom, i am excited by the discourse and the student growth in mathematical reasoning ive seen so far in my classroom. A framework for cultivating student led discussions use conversation to raise student learning. Ive developed seven tips that can help you and students as you collaborate to develop productive and meaningful discussions.
There are many popular strategies for these kinds of conversations, each with slightly unique rules and applications. We published a version of this manual intalking studentslistening teachers. See more ideas about teaching, teaching reading and reading workshop. In studentled discussions, author sandi novak offers you the resources you. Consider the consequences of being unprepared for a book discussion. Recognize and evaluate effective studentled discussions.
Effects of literature discussion groups on reading comprehension. Studentled conversations in book clubs inspire me asap. I found this especially useful while preparing 12th grade students for university. Lasting from 5 to 30 minutes, these discussions might extend over several class periods because students need the time to analyze and think critically. Teachers give introductions to the books in order to help stu. During meaningful conversations, students are forced to be accountable for their positions, to listen, to analyze opposing perspectives, and to adapt their thinking on the fly. Want your students to have rich, complex conversations about the texts they. Lets first identify some characteristics of student led conversations with book clubs. Three approaches to guiding your students to take ownership over their. Conducting studentcentered discussion the great books. One part of our literacy program, readygen, is called team talk. Guidebook for studentcentered classroom discussions.
Going beyond thinkpairshare for paired and small group discussions. Four steps to deepen student discussions about math. Use leveled books in student led discussions ela in the. Students are placed into a few groups of 46 students each and are given a discussion question to talk about. Sandi novak is an education consultant and author of the ascd arias student led discussions. One or two student led discussions occur within the school year. Recognize and evaluate effective student led discussions. This product is my way of generating an authentic student led discussion. Access free reproducible versions of tools and rubrics featured in the book, including discussion formats that are useful for literacybased. She has more than 30 years of experience as an assistant superintendent, principal, curriculum. I use these discussions in my class to gauge my student s learning as an alternative to a reading quiz.
It includes methods that encourage critical thinking through discussion and debate. Opinion texts writing task movies are more enjoyable than books. A powerful form of thinking and communicating, student led conversations can last from five to 15 minutes and bring social interactions to students learning. Begin with material students are familiar with or feel comfortable with. Sep 11, 20 great books, great student discussions conducting studentcentered discussion in the classroom by samantha cleaver every time her students get ready to talk about a piece of reading, amber damm, a seventh and eighthgrade teacher at clara barton open school of south minneapolis, mn, arranges her. Younger students can lead discussions too small groups, big. Gale rhodes contact information robert schaible, professor of arts and humanities, lewistonauburn college. We began by having students bring books to whole and smallgroup activities and encouraging them to talk. Until then i had been running discussions in the familiar way. Students have authentic conversations and is not rolebased. Sandi novak is an education consultant and author of the ascd arias studentled discussions. Download the grapes of wrath discussion topics and writing prompts by chapter as a word file 123kbdiscipline. Prize in american studies for his 2004 book emancipating pragmatism.
Follow take action prompts to exercise newly acquired knowledge and make learning content standards more exciting. Scholastic reading summit student led book discussions english sol, selfdirected learning skills, and 21st century skills richmond, va july 23, 20 a free powerpoint ppt presentation displayed as a flash slide show on id. Designing effective discussion questions teaching commons. Not all mathematical discussions have the same aim or should be led in the same way. Ask questions that prompt students to make personal judgments. In addition to providing a discussion framework that requires students to think deeply and communicate effectively, the includes advice for how to introduce and cultivate student led discussions about literary and informational material at any grade.
Use leveled books in student led discussions ela in the middle. This is a helpful resource for generating discussion and organizing literature circles in your classroom. Understand your role as the teacher when students are leading their own discussions. Decide on the number of studentled book discussions you will have each week. Aug 08, 2017 what is the difference between teacher led and student led discussions. In addition to providing a discussion framework that requires students to think deeply and communicate effectively, she includes advice for how to. The mediational tools included fishbowl discussions, writing prompts, flexible grouping, and student selfevaluation checklists. Check back frequently, as well continue to add additional resources. Establish core instructional elements that students need to engage in rich discussions about content. Listen for how students personalize the discussion, and encourage them to develop their own voice. Implementing literature discussion groups in classrooms enhanced. We modeled and analyzed discussions in front of the class, using our resources to evaluate the questions and participation. Use leveled books in student led discussions middleweb. Students learn what to share as we prompt them to articulate important parts of their explanations.
When students are in charge of discussing books they selected and can read, motivation and engagement soar. Do you want to ensure that all students develop strong speaking and listening skills. If youve got lessons plans, videos, activities, or other ideas youd like to contribute, wed love to hear from you. Complete this quick questionnaire to help us plan upcoming student discussions. These studentled discussion strategies will have your students engaged and thinking. They were able to read a chapter and answer the questions as a group. Deeper class discussions with the tqe method cult of pedagogy. This is an opportunity to use questions, prompts, and cues to help students complete tasks. By early november we were just about ready to start our student led discussions. These are some great ideas that can be implemented in the classroom to help student led discussions. This book provides a discussion framework that requires students to think deeply and communicate effectively.
Thompson and wegmann 2011 found that public blogs implemented with students in place of online discussions could realize many of the benefits of online discussions. Apr 24, 2018 while they have many benefits, student led discussions often create unintended consequences that inhibit their effectiveness. Discussion prompts may summarize aspects, in the reading, that are of greatest interest to the facilitator, or may result from the most oblique of references arising from the reading. Each of the four segments of the facilitating student led discussions series provides a 30minute standalone session appropriate for k12 professional development in all subjectscontents during faculty meetings, before or after school, or during teacher planning time. Prompts for student led discussions about the book. I used this for my higher reading group to work independently. Examine students thoughts about being involved in their own student led discussions. This method prompts students to uncover their own meaning from challenging texts through deep discussion and questioning.
Excerpt the 6th grade lesson began like any other typical classroom activity. By continuing to use this site, you are accepting the use of these cookies. Students then use the strategy to develop questions for a peer led book discussion. This might be a question that can be answered with information from general experience or from basic data in the subject area. Many times the original post reads more like a report and then the replies are good job or i agree because there is nowhere to go. Eric ed465995 scaffolding in a learning community of.
Are you looking to enhance your teaching of higherorder thinking and 21st century skills. Each of the four segments of the facilitating studentled discussions series provides a 30minute standalone session appropriate for k12 professional development in all subjectscontents during faculty meetings, before or after school, or during teacher planning time. Chunk books by having students read three to four chapters, then stop to hold a partner or small group studentled discussion on that section. After years of experimentation with studentled discussions, ive honed three. How do i promote rich conversations about books, videos, and other media. Laura robb november 11th, 2016 all we do is read a few chapters and do worksheets. Give students enough time to flip through and find just the right piece of evidence. A powerful form of thinking and communicating, studentled conversations can last from five to 15 minutes and bring social interactions to students learning.
Students respond to a question or write about a topic for a set amount of time before passing the paper to a partner. In other words, once students have established a basic knowledge base through lecture, readings, or other content delivery methods, discussions help them learn deeply and extend their learning to new circumstances. Jul 20, 2014 are you interested in having your student join an online discussion led by one of our expert great books trainers. The article included a description of student led discussions for an online course. The way to engage your students in classroom book discussions is to simply. You may notice something that all the groups are missing in their discussion. If other students are getting antsy, choose one of your alwaysready students to share, then loop back to the student who needed time with the text. When designing instruction and preparing for studentled discussions, it is.
Small group, individual, full class, ongoing, teacher led discussion, student led discussion, critical analysis, writing. Practice listening to others courteously by participating in discussions. Ela teaching strategies for small group discussions. Beezus and ramona by beverly cleary discussion cards. Any larger than this, and you risk some students opting out of the discussion or simply being overshadowed by others in the group. Sunday cummins is a literacy consultant and author. Once students have built a repertoire of authentic starters and prompts, create an anchor chart that makes their language a part of your class. What the students will say while the teacher is away reading. What makes an effective online course, sparked some lively discussion on our online teaching listserv. Guidebook for student centered classroom discussions page 3 1b a contrast of student centered and faculty led discussion learning is an interactive process between the student, the teacher, and the subject matter. A book discussion group is a forum where readers can come together and talk about books and the reading experience. This partner then writes for another set amount of time. Whereas the ideal group size for student led discussions in third grade and beyond is four to six, young students do better in groups of two to three. The group size is an important consideration when planning for student led discussions.
The big list of class discussion strategies cult of pedagogy. Studentled discussion groups appropriate student level. Chunk books by having students read three to four chapters, then stop to hold a partner or small group student led discussion on that section. Today, i am writing specifically about studentled conversations in book clubs. Studentled discussions develop 21stcentury learning.
I survived the childrens blizzard, 1888 discussion. A framework for cultivating student led discussions use conversation to raise student learning, motivation, and engagement in k12 classrooms sandi novak, cara slattery on. There are many good books that can help you moderate good classroom discussions. Time allocation grades 312 each student led discussion cycle takes about one to three weeks. A week before the discussion, the facilitator posts a set of discussion prompts based on the reading, on the class blog. Feb 03, 2017 3 tips for running successful student led book clubs have you always wanted to run book clubs in your classroom, but youre just not sure how to set them up, keep your readers accountable, or get your students reading, writing and talking deeply about books. Student led discussion strategies for whole class discussion. Discussion prompts teaching online pedagogical repository. Students are introduced to the questionanswer relationship qar strategy through a readaloud and question sort. As part of a collaborative study, wea firstgrade teacher and two universitybased researchersset a goal to facilitate meaningful, studentled discussions about literature. One student assumes the role of a book character, significant figure in history, or concept such as a. During guided instructional events, teachers use talk to determine what students know and what they still need to know. Contains 42 references and 4 childrens books cited. How to use math talk cardsposters to promote studentled.
Student led discussions offers teachers the resources they need to develop meaningful student led conversations about text and media across the content areas. Amount of time for students to discuss ranges from two to fifteen minutes. Studentled discussions develop 21stcentury learning skills. Invite them to discuss a story or several chapters in a book. Better studentled literature discussions choice literacy. In the case study, scaffolding was shown to create opportunities for students to practice and develop their literacy knowledge and skills. There are adult groups, student led groups, motherdaughter groups, fatherson groups, and parentchild groups, to. Take notes during student conferences and use them to check for understanding and to show growth throughout the process. We like having the students pose a question at the end of their post to prompt better discussions. I thought it was important to be clear about what would need to happen during the discussions to avoid the chaotic meetings of the year before.
1270 1143 64 501 302 511 542 1498 127 679 48 963 1017 1185 575 881 717 93 477 1258 19 92 506 219 363 1239 355 667 989